My goal was to be coming home from Jurisdictional Conference
excited about the future of the church.
I don’t know if “excited” is the word that best fits. I am
excited / scared / embarrassed / happy / proud / angry / inspired / hopeful.
What’s the word for that emotion? It may be "terrifyingly wonderful," but could also be "wonderfully terrifying." You pick.
So this will be kind of rambly, almost stream of
consciousness. But somewhere in what follows will be the beginnings of my
thoughts about what happened at the 2016 meeting of the South Central
Jurisdiction of the United Methodist Church. Here goes...
I’ll start with the Missouri Annual Conference’s new bishop,
Bishop Bob Farr. Who, at this time last week, was Missouri’s Director of
Congregational Excellence. He is a colleague and a friend to many in Missouri,
and now he is our bishop. That dynamic is … unusual.
It is extremely rare for a bishop to be elected and
immediately assigned to her or his home conference. It is not forbidden in our
rule book, but it is hardly ever done. No one on the Missouri delegation could
remember it happening before in our Jurisdiction.
I’m excited about Bishop Farr’s election and assignment for
two reasons. First of all, it is an unusual situation, a new and different way
to organize, and that’s what Missouri is all about! We are not now, nor we ever
have been known for doing the same ol’ same ol’. Bishop Farr’s leadership will
be innovative, just by its very nature. And secondly, I am excited that the
South Central Jurisdiction has finally managed to elect a bishop who is not
from the state of Texas. Not that that’s a huge deal, but it was starting to
get kind of monotonous.
Bishop Farr is going to continue to focus on local
congregations, and equip, encourage, and allow churches to organize for and
engage in ministry that makes sense and bears fruit in the wide variety of
diverse contexts around our state. He loves the church with all his heart, and
loves Jesus just as much. I am happy and proud to call him my bishop.
With that said, I am embarrassed by the lack of diversity
among the bishops of the South Central Jurisdiction. There is only one active
bishop who is a woman, for example. Rev. Lynn Dyke would be a phenomenal
bishop, and I was working to help her election happen until the moment she
removed herself from consideration. Furthermore, Rev. David Wilson is a gifted
leader, and would have brought a new perspective to the council of bishops,
that of a Native American. Neither was elected.
There are ten bishops in the SCJ, and NINE of them are men,
and SEVEN of them are white men. This is embarrassing to me, and not at all
reflective of who we are as United Methodists. But it should be noted that
across our denomination the other Jurisdictions have done a better job of
electing bishops who reflect our diversity, including four African-American
women.
With THAT said, the voting in the South Central Jurisdiction
was neither sexist nor racist. Those making such claims are making some huge
assumptions, often without actually being present during the conference. Both
Lynn and David were in the thick of it on many ballots; David received over a
hundred votes on one (ballot 24).
I am not naive, so I know that there were some individuals
likely voting based on gender and/or race. But anyone who claims the final
outcome was blatantly sexist or obviously racist would have a lot of explaining
to do to back that assumption up. And based on my experience there, there were
a myriad of other factors involved with the decisions the delegates made in
selecting bishops.
(Um, isn’t that point a contradiction to the previous one?
Yes. Sure seems like it. Are you still wondering why my
reaction is so mixed up?)
Next thing: The politicking made me angry. There’s no other
way to say it. It makes me angry when a delegation huddles up, then the next
ballot has a large number of votes for a random person who had zero on the
previous ballot. Or two delegations get together and then on the next ballot
one candidate who was running well has dropped while another one has bumped up.
Deals are offered, bargains are struck, delegations “fish” for attractive candidates,
heels are dug in. People campaign. And it’s politics. And I did it too. I was a
part of it, in the mix. It is what it is, and that doesn’t mean I have to like
it. If there’s a better way to do it, I’m all for giving it a try.
Then there was this: A surreal moment happened on Friday
night. Simultaneously to the election of Bishop Karen Oliveto, we in the South
Central Jurisdiction were debating whether or not to send a request to the
Judicial Council of the UMC for a ruling on the election and consecration of
people who are gay to be bishops in the United Methodist Church. (FYI, Bishop
Oliveto is gay).
It was well rehearsed, planned out in advance, and timed
exquisitely. As the petition was read from the floor, slides on screen
displayed the text. It was pretty obvious that it had been in the works for a
while, to be initiated if it looked like a gay bishop was close to election.
The vote was close, but we voted to go ahead and submit the
request. People who believe that sexual orientation is not a hinderance to
ordination think that this move is an attack on inclusiveness. People who think
being gay disqualifies someone from ordination think this move is simply trying
to be obedient to the Book of Discipline. So it goes.
And then, immediately after the vote, my friend and fellow
Missouri delegate Andrew Ponder Williams went to the microphone and asked that
we stand and pray, specifically for all who had been “hurt by what just
happened.” I know exactly what he meant, but the way he worded it, he may have
meant hurt by Bishop Oliveto’s election OR hurt by the South Central
Jurisdiction’s request. After some urging by Justin Coleman, essentially the
entire room came and gathered around Andrew, who was by the way standing two
feet in front of me. We connected hands on shoulders, hand in hand, reaching
for whoever was closest.
And then Andrew prayed. And it was a remarkable prayer.
Sensitive, passionate, grace-filled, loving. The Holy Spirit fell upon Andrew
in that moment, and he prayed for us. It was amazing, and I will never forget
it.
Rob Renfroe has said that the election of Bishop Oliveto has
put us on “the brink of schism.” He was sitting just a few feet on the other
side of the microphone from which Andrew was speaking. I am sad to say that I
did not notice if he stood up to pray with the rest of the group, but I am
assuming that he did. If he did, he was literally three or four people away
from Andrew.
Several people have asked me what I think about Bishop
Oliveto’s election and assignment to the Mountain Sky Area. I don’t know; I’ve
never even met her, much less have any thoughts about her potential
effectiveness as a bishop. What I do know is that she is an ordained elder in
the United Methodist Church, a member of the California-Nevada Annual
Conference, she was nominated for bishop by her Annual Conference, and duly
elected bishop by the Western Jurisdiction. I trust that process, and the
people involved in it, in their discernment of Bishop Oliveto’s call to be a
bishop.
And here is another thing of which I am certain. The gender
of the person that Bishop Oliveto happens to love has no impact on the gifts
and graces that God has given her to serve in ministry. Nor, by the by, does it
have an impact on how we are going to do ministry at Campbell UMC in
Springfield. I’m not going to obsess over that aspect of her identity, and I
hope you won’t either.
One of the inspiring and hopeful parts of Jurisdictional
Conference was meeting and getting to know some really cool people from around
the South-Central Jurisdiction. It’s all about relationships, making
connections with one another, and I had a lot of opportunities to do just that
in Wichita. And by the wonder that is social media, it will be so much easier
to remain connected.
I love being a part of a connectional church. I love the
frustrating, beautiful, messy diversity that comprises our “big tent”
denomination. I still don’t know what’s going to happen. People may leave now
that we have a gay bishop. Other people may leave if the Judicial Council comes
back and rules her election invalid.
I’m not leaving. I am Methodist, through and through. God
has called me to serve in the United Methodist Church in this unsettled,
uncertain season. The open table, the way of salvation, knowledge joined with
piety, personal and social holiness together, grace upon grace upon grace -
Methodism has something beautiful to offer people, and I’m all about offering
it.
The Holy Spirit is so obviously at work in the church, in
the nation, in the world, creating new expressions of church, deconstructing
outdated ways of organizing, reviving old forms and practices in new and
creative ways, tossing away old wineskins and providing brand new ones. What a
truly terrifying and coincidentally wonderful time to be a part of the United
Methodist Church!
8 comments:
Thank you for answering my question and those of so many others, Andy. I am no longer UM, but I enjoy following what's going on in the UMC, and I am still Wesleyan through and through.
Thank you for answering my question and those of so many others, Andy. I am no longer UM, but I enjoy following what's going on in the UMC, and I am still Wesleyan through and through.
Great reflection on an aspect of the church that is important to our future.
So disappointed that the BiBLE and the Book of Discipline have not been followed. God help us.
Perspective: 9% of the American United Methodists are in defiance of the General Conference and you question why the remaining 91% (not to mention the 94% global) want to know if the rules have changed or if any conferences/jurisdictions are exempt? Whole churches have already left the denomination over less. When considering a global denomination of 12 million, specially considering the deferment of the issue to the COB at the GC, what the WJ did was selfish and myopic. Who will pay the bills when one side leaves? The WJ? I applaud what your conference's action.
Thanks for articulating this so well. In particular, thanks for sharing the struggle.
A simple thank-you for your thoughts and clarity.
I think it is sad that you spent so much energy trying to justify your position on this issue.
My Jesus loves all people regardless of their race, gender, ethnicity or their sexual orientation. We all have been given gifts that we can use to serve the church. We are all sinners. God is dismayed by this discussion
Post a Comment